You are currently not logged in.  Logon or register to access more features. Vision-Riders.com is a FREE service provided by Victory Riders Network.

Search:




Poll ABS brakes
Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 2 [25 messages per page]
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Discussion -> Vision DiscussionMessage format
 
ABS brakes
OptionResults
I would prefer ABS on the Vision44 Votes - [72.13%]
I prefer non-ABS on the Vision17 Votes - [27.87%]

varyder
Posted 2008-07-23 3:39 PM (#14240 - in reply to #14231)
Subject: RE: ABS brakes


Visionary

Posts: 8144
New Bohemia, VA
SongFan - 2008-07-23 1:38 PM

People have been killed by airbags and trapped by seatbelts but the positives far outweigh the negatives.  ABS is the same thing.  You can find people who will say it didn't work for them in a certain situation but in 99% of the cases it is used in, it is better.  I notice that the riders who have had ABS on a bike and wouldn't go back outweigh the ones who preferred the old style 100:1 (that's probably conservative). 

I've had the brakes on my Connie lock up on a wet road pulling up to an intersection at less than 10 mph.  I didn't go down but it sure put my heart in my throat.  I like the idea of being able to lock down on the brakes and still steer through a situation.

If you've never ridden a bike with ABS I don't think you have a lot of credibiltiy to say which is better.  I personally like the linked brakes on the Vision but if I had $1400 and had to choose between reverse or ABS, I'd go ABS in a heartbeat.  Every ABS story I've read sounds more like "I wouldn't be here if it weren't for the ABS." than "It sucks.  I wish I had my old brakes back."

90% of American riders don't take motorcycle safety courses and until that changes they need all the help they can get.

Sorry to keep this post going, but it is a good one for all to think about. There is a wide spectrim of opinions, from, it doesn't matter to I've got to have ABS. You mentioned that 90% of American riders don't take the safety course, and statistic shows that there is a direct correlation in number of registered motorcycles to the number of crashes and fatalities. The stats below are for the Commonwealth of Virginia. Now, given the number of registered motorcycles, how many are actually ridden and what are the stats on that relationship. We'll never know, however, often when there is a motorcycle fatality I read that speed, inexperience and sometimes alcohol is a factor. Occassionally there is the cut-off, pull out in front of, moved into by a cager. There again this data can be skewed and there are no reports of accident avoidance because of ABS.

While station at Fort Bragg in the 80's the safety sign coming into Fort Bragg only displayed motorcycle accidents, even though there were many other type of accidents not even related to motorcycles. I also I felt I was targeted only because I rode, but the perception was from the fast riders, typically the crouch-rocket riders, but because I was on a motorcycle I was tagged a wild out of control biker. But this is also caused by our community by the many comments here, that there needs to be a safety course for new riders. So to see that 90% do not take a course says that there are many lucky people out there. I think our community needs to remind one another to keep up with knowing what our bikes do and not just ride them. I'm guilty in that I was on my bike for 3 years after 20 years before I took another safety course, but I'm glad I finally did. It was good to get the safety course information, but sharing with one another made all the difference, just as we are doing here. It's all about riding another day. 

Year Motorcyclists killed Motorcycle crashesRegistered motorcycles
1999381,32072,120
2000451,52550,190
2001441,74389,654
2002541,648100,230
2003561,713109,288
2004562,000123,548
2005682,289136,978
2006702,499151,914

So as you rightly suggest SongFan, I have no credibility when it comes to ABS, and I wouldn't even listen to me when making a decision to go with or not to go with ABS. I just don't ever recall a time that I stopped quickly and felt I could have done a better job with ABS. In the last 34 months I've been riding, logging over 75,000 miles for an average of 2,200+ per month, I can't think of one time that I locked my brakes to stop. I've had a few quick or "panic" stops, but no lock up or skids. This is riding in all kinds of conditions, night, winter, city, interstate, country, even gravel. I've even done 1K+ in 19 hours and 1.5k in 36 hours, all smooth sailing on the veins of craziness. And I can count on one hand the number of panic stops. But as my wife would say, "Don't think it won't happen though."

The situation we are faced with is that on some models you do not have a choice, ABS is what you'll get. So my apologies to those who did not get ABS on your first Vision because of folk like me that prefer not to have it. But as it would be, your next Vision, and mine, will have this coveted technology. Let's just make sure we know how it will react before we have to use it.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
SongFan
Posted 2008-07-23 3:59 PM (#14241 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: RE: ABS brakes


Visionary

Posts: 3204
Memphis

Chris,

You have totally valid points.  I've ridden a couple of bikes with ABS but have never owned one.  The closest I've come to a wreck was when a little old lady in a Crown Vic pulled out of a side street in my neighborhood without looking.  I stopped about 6" from her drivers door as she slammed on her brakes when she saw me.  I could have stopped about 3 feet short but ran it in tight while going to the high beams to scare the crap out of her.  It was about 35mph on a dry road and ABS wouldn't have made a difference.  On dry pavement test riders can often stop shorter without ABS. 

Where I see it helping me is when conditions are less than perfect.  I ride the Vision in much lousier weather than ever before.  Just because I've never locked up the brakes doesn't mean I won't.  With ABS, I can't lock it up on a wet road.  That is a nice safety net.

The accident/fatality numbers will only get worse as more bikes and cars hit the road.  ABS or not.

Top of the page Bottom of the page
exharleyrider
Posted 2008-07-23 5:19 PM (#14244 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Cruiser

Posts: 247
i guess that makes me a moron, a liar and and delusional. hope younever have to lay it down on purpose. crow tastes bad.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
varyder
Posted 2008-07-23 6:06 PM (#14247 - in reply to #14244)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Visionary

Posts: 8144
New Bohemia, VA

exharleyrider - 2008-07-23 5:19 PM i guess that makes me a moron, a liar and and delusional. hope younever have to lay it down on purpose. crow tastes bad.

XHR, I take it that you've put it down "on purpose." First, if you have, I'm glad you survived. Second, I think as a biker we learn a lot along the way, and really, most of us have a different outlook on life. So doing whatever we thought was the best and survived, makes us anything but a moron, liar or delusional, but it sounds you were describing me, cause I can fit those categories at any given moment. I'm an ignorant liar, but a bonifide, card carrying moron who is often delusional. I don't consider myself any sort of expert rider and statistically at greater risk of an accident than probably most on this forum. I've got maybe a total of 6 years of riding in a 24 year time frame, though I have carried my M endorsement for that entire time. Out of those six years I might have 140,000 miles, maybe. So the average of that would be about 5,800 miles a year, or that of an average rider. But I would say the one thing that we should all have is respect for what we do. I jumped out of a perfectly good airplane about 65 times in my Army career and each time I had a tremendous amount of respect up to the very end. Every mile I ride on my bike, I have a tremendous amount of respect for each mile. I learn from everyone who rides. So can you tell us about your laydown? If not so sweat, or you can PM me, I'm curious. 

Top of the page Bottom of the page
RotnRat
Posted 2008-07-23 8:03 PM (#14265 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: RE: ABS brakes


Cruiser

Posts: 117
South of Houston Tx
I am not to proud to tell of my youthful ignorance that brought me to the point of an intentional lay-down. It was about 25 years ago maybe more on a KZ 750 directly after a bottle of wild turkey. I was with a group of others at a little state park in north western Oklahoma (Boiling Springs State Park) It was early spring and as the sun set it started to cool off so the majority vote was to move the party to town. We all took off towards town but I remembered that I left my cigarettes on the picnic table so I went back after them. The road from this park had a 15 MPH curve right after leaving then a 35 MPH about a half mile or so further. I remembered the 15 MPH curve but forgot all about the other one, as soon as I came out of the first curve I nailed it with plans of catching up to my friends, when I saw the next curve I looked at my speedo and was doing 130 but got her down to just under 100 when I went into it. I had it in the pebbles of the oncoming traffics shoulder with my right pegs scraping pavement. when I made it far enough around to see the other direction I saw headlights coming right at me so I made the decision to let go, really wasn't any laying down because it was down as far as it could go, I just got off. I didn't have a helmet on, I did have a light jacket jeans and boots, so as I tumbled out through the sage brush it sort of knocked me senseless and caused me to lose my bearings. I stood up and was trying to figure out where I was when I heard the vehicle, whose headlights I saw, come to a screeching halt from behind me. I walked back towards the road from some 100 yards or so out in the sage brush and climbed over the barb wire fence, that I must have slid under, to find my bike lodged in the fence a few posts down. my hand was ripped open from my wrist half way up my thumb, I assume from covering my face going under the barb wire, my jacket and jeans were shredded and I had some more cuts from the barb wire on my legs but nothing deep like on my hand, I still sport the scar there to always remind me that drinking and motorcycles don't mix. The guy in the oncoming car's name was Billy Kidd, I have always remembered that because it was so unusual, anyway he told me " I haven't been out of the house for a month and after seeing that I'm not leaving it again for a long time", he gave me his shirt to wrap my hand in and then took me home were I stumbled in and passed out on the couch completely in shock and shivering like it was 10 below. The next day I found that nearly every muscle in my body was pulled and I wasn't able to walk for almost 2 weeks. but as soon as I was able to limp good I went to the impound yard and got the motorcycle back, it ran fine although the seat was tore up and the turn stop was bent. ABS brakes or any other safety feature wouldn't have helped for that one but at least I learned from it.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bigfoot
Posted 2008-08-01 2:47 PM (#14927 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Tourer

Posts: 494
Akron Ohio area
As I had expected, more than 70% of members in this forum would value the "Option" of ABS brakes.
Sadly I will have to wait yet another year and hope Victory finally comes around in 2010.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
rainmaker
Posted 2008-08-01 10:04 PM (#14955 - in reply to #14040)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Cruiser

Posts: 72
Eden Prairie, MN
pollolittle - 2008-07-22 7:44 AM

1) Newer Motorcycles are equipped with ABS.

2) Motorcycle accidents are an all-time high.

So from that I can blame ABS for the rise.

HUH? Sometiimes I wonder who the sane one is around here. While there is no way to be able to put stats to this, I have a quarter to put into this mix. I ride like Varyder, always looking! And like CjNoMOHD, I continually try to give my gear a work out and figure out how it responds to different environments, including braking. While mine may not have come with it, I would probably enjoy it, if it worked like a car's ABS and help maintain control. All of the ABS systems I have used in an emergency situation have been awesome. Able to go around, instead of into.
Unlike a Motorcycle racer who stays on the edge of his equipment and can out brake and accelerate past just about all of us on here, I think it would be a good addition to have. I know I don't see enough hard braking or accelerating to be properly conditioned to react all the time. Even with all the courses out there and knowledge, most if not all of us just CRUISE long distances without ever touching the brakes. With that said I think it would still be an awesome item to mark on the order sheet, if it worked!

Nice!
Top of the page Bottom of the page
rainmaker
Posted 2008-08-01 10:29 PM (#14961 - in reply to #14927)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Cruiser

Posts: 72
Eden Prairie, MN
Bigfoot.
I love a good discussion and this "debate" is no exception. There are a number of characterstics that make the Vision a remarkably safe bike to ride. Balance, suspension handling, center of gravity, linked brakes, etc. Certainly, putting ABS on it would add to the list.

But I also know putting ABS on a bike doesn't automatically make it safer. I'm not going to pick on any brand, but putting technology on a bike for the sake of technology doesn't make the bike any better. If you lock up your wheels frequently, you've got other issues. You need to rethink how, or where you ride.

I've said this before, maybe not to you, but if your not riding a Vision because it doesn't have ABS, you're missing out on a hell of a riding experience for the wrong reasons.

Are you going to wait for air bags too.

Really, I don't get why you hang out here an piss on Victory. Have you noticed the absense of people on this site who are sorry they bought one?

Come on, join us or go piss on somthing else.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
varyder
Posted 2008-08-02 12:09 AM (#14972 - in reply to #14961)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Visionary

Posts: 8144
New Bohemia, VA

And it goes on. This is one of those things that will naturally take on a majority to have as a "safety feature". I really don't want to discount the good ABS has to offer, but I'm with Rainmaker, don't give it to me for the sake of giving it to me. If I were to have a series of close calls, or lock ups or anything else that would make be seriously question the notion of riding, I believe I would park it, no I would sell it. The Vision is the first bike I've owned that makes riding a true joy. I love to ride and do so everyday, 365 days a year, yes, even in Virginia.

I find in this world there are many things that gives one a preceived notion of benefit. I can open a can of worms here, but vitamins are one of those things. It is a billion dollar industry that serves little purpose. Eating healthy is the way to go, people can believe if they are taking vitamins it is a substitute to eating healthy, but I believe that vitamins offer little or no benefit whatsoever. Yet, we were told growing up to "take your vitamins." I do, everyday, by eating vegatable, drinking real juice and so on. Do I eat perfect, no. Is my cholesterol through the roof? Yes. But so is my dad's and he's 80. We have a family history of high cholestarol and long life. So, should I take a cholesterol medicene that has an arm long list of side-affects to include serious health issues, or do I continue marching forward as the rest of my family and "take my chance" with high cholesterol. I'll take my chances and attempt to eat healthy regularly. By the way, my BP is still at a healthy level and I'm quickly approaching 50. I take ZERO medication, though my wife thinks I should be on for mental reasons.

So, now that I rambled and stirred a pot, back to the subject of ABS. I trust the sturdiness and the handling of my machine, but riding to the best of my ability, which includes some formentioned focus points, is what I need to rely on. I'm sure ABS will be forced upon me sometime or another if I continue to ride, I have them in my jeeps without a choice. But I will not put my trust in ABS in compromise to my riding ability. When I do, it will be time to park the 'er and get back to four-wheeling. I rest. 



Edited by varyder 2008-08-02 12:11 AM
Top of the page Bottom of the page
metalguy
Posted 2008-08-02 1:02 AM (#14976 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Tourer

Posts: 550
Tacoma, WA
I have taken the ERC many times, and it should be something everyone who rides often should consider doing regularly. I too ride year-around, and have for many years. Not long ago, I was riding my Father's Valk to and from work, starting in my deeply muddied driveway. I saw no flaws with the brakes, BTW! Fine motorcycle. I rode it to Sturgis in 2006, and my Harley budies just couldn't keep up! We rode through hail, and rain, and the wonderful construction in yellowstone by the Cody Wyoming entrance...ABS may be fine, but proper training is a must!-----Metalguy
Top of the page Bottom of the page
dwhite28
Posted 2008-08-02 1:04 AM (#14977 - in reply to #13848)
Subject: Re: ABS brakes


Tourer

Posts: 404
San Antonio, TX United States
I have to say that i am glad to hear that there are some other riders that ride 365 days a year. I live in Chesapeake and ride every day by choice. I have ridden every day by choice for the last 10 years. (Except for a short 3 year period i was rebuilding my bike and letting a shoulder injury heal after being rear ended in a hit and run) I would like to ride an ABS bike and push it to its limits and see where it and my abilities meet and possibly push the limits somemore.

I could go on about the pros and cons of this issue just as much as anyone else but to no avail. I would lke the option of the ABS, not forced on me. I have had the misfortune of sliding my bike on its side because of the wheels locking up from someone pulling out in front of me at the last minute. I honestly can not say whether the ABS would have made a difference due to the car being so very close as they pulled out. I have been traveling at 50 MPH with my wife on the back when a car full of teenagers rolled through a stop sign and cars were in left lane which left me with almost no where to go. Thank god i take time to practice every now and then in a closed parking lot and know what i pretty much can get away with. I was able to swerve hard to the left side of the lane right on the dotted line and miss the vehicle. My wife commented that if she had not raised her leg, she probably would have contacted the car. ABS or regular brakes would have made no difference.

My point being that whether you ride with ABS or not, please take time to practice and push on the edge of your limits now and then. Know what your bike can do and what you can do. Part of the big trick is knowing your limits and handling an emergency situation with out getting your blood pressure up and being excited. When you grab a handful off brake, you loose steering control due to the muscles being constricted in your right arm. If you panic and have ABS and stomp down hard on the foot brake, you will cause you bike to steer to the right and now you have to adjusted with your arms stiff from grabbing a lot of brake and being in a panic. We can never be vigilant enough when we are riding and planning our escape route every few seconds in case some body on the road decides to occupy the space you are in. We have to train ourselve on our time and at our expense if we drop the bike while learning to be a better rider.

I relinguish my soapbox now for the next person. Just ride safe, enjoy the fact that many of us do ride every day in all kinds of wheather becuase we choose to.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
rdbudd
Posted 2008-08-02 2:00 PM (#15015 - in reply to #14231)
Subject: RE: ABS brakes


Visionary

Posts: 1632
Jasper, MO
I can't make the claim that I have ridden a bike with ABS. However, I have driven personal vehicles and semi-trucks both with and without ABS. I can testify, without doubt, from personal experience, that ABS increases the stopping distance in a panic-stop situation. ABS on the semi I drive does save a bunch of expensive tires, but it DEFINITELY increases the stopping distance compared to what it is if I have to lock up the brakes. I found this out the hard way. I despise ABS. It's a poor replacement for skill. As has already been stated by others, training, experience, and practice are the keys to saving your bacon in a bad situation. A mechanical bandaid is no replacement. No ABS on a bike for me please.

Ronnie

Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 2 [25 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

Copyright © 2007-2025 Victory Riders Network™